Senator Bernie Sanders has raised concerns that recent claims about waste and fraud in the Social Security system could be a prelude to privatizing the program. In an interview with CNN, Sanders stated that lying about Social Security “is a prelude not only to cutting benefits but to privatizing Social Security itself.”
The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE), led by Elon Musk, has announced plans to cut 12% of the Social Security Administration (SSA) workforce, reducing staff from 57,000 to 50,000. The department also intends to consolidate 10 regional offices into four and close 45 field offices nationwide.
Musk has made several claims about Social Security, calling it “a mechanism by which the Democrats attract and retain illegal immigrants” and referring to it as the “biggest Ponzi scheme of all time.” President Donald Trump has echoed these claims, asserting that millions of deceased individuals are still receiving Social Security checks. However, audits have debunked these claims. Under the Biden administration, an audit of Social Security payments from 2015 to 2022 found that most improper payments were overpayments, not payments to deceased individuals.
The Office of the Inspector General identified $72 billion in improper payments, less than 1% of total benefits distributed over seven years.
Bernie Sanders questions misinformation motives
Sanders questioned the motives behind the misinformation, asking, “So why do you lie so much about Social Security?
Why do you make it look like a broken, dysfunctional system?” He suggested that the reason is to undermine public faith in the system, making it easier to privatize. Social Security faces long-term funding challenges, with projections indicating that the program will run out of funds by 2034. Several options exist to address the shortfall, such as raising the retirement age, eliminating the taxable income cap, or increasing payroll tax rates.
Privatization advocates argue that the private sector could manage the program more effectively, giving workers more control and potentially higher returns. However, critics warn that privatization carries significant risks, as evidenced by the impact of the 2008 financial crisis on 401(k) plans. As the debate continues, the future of Social Security remains uncertain, with significant implications for millions of Americans who rely on the program for their retirement.
Photo by realnewsforever; Pixabay